# The Myth of the 21-Day Habit Formation: Understanding Real Change
Written on
Chapter 1: The 21-Day Myth
Many people are familiar with the popular notion that forming a new habit or breaking an old one takes just twenty-one days. This idea is appealing because three weeks seems both long enough to commit to a change and short enough to be achievable.
My swimming coach once suggested that if we simply focused on doing our best for three weeks, it would eventually become second nature. However, this approach raises several questions. How intricate can a habit be? Is it truly 21 days for every type of habit? What if you miss a day during those twenty-one days? Does it reset your progress? And is the timeline the same for everyone?
When examining specific instances, the idea quickly unravels. For example, I have consistently woken up around 7 AM for most of my adult life—often for much longer than 21 days. Yet, I have frequently struggled with this routine and tend to sleep in on days without early commitments.
Section 1.1: The Origin of the 21-Day Rule
The 21-day concept can be traced back to the 1950s when a plastic surgeon observed that it took patients about 21 days to adjust to their "new faces." He later published a successful book on this topic, which sold over 30 million copies.
Maxwell Maltz, the author of "Psycho-Cybernetics," stated, “It requires a minimum of about 21 days for an old mental image to dissolve and a new one to jell.” Unfortunately, this statement was often taken out of context. As self-help authors popularized his findings, the belief that 21 days was the magical number for habit formation took hold and spread widely.
People began to think that enduring something for 21 days would magically switch on their ability to adopt good habits. This perspective is fundamentally flawed.
Subsection 1.1.1: Rethinking Habit Formation
To effectively build a habit, it is crucial to eliminate the barriers hindering you. Rather than viewing it as an obligation, consider how to frame the habit in a way that makes you genuinely want to engage with it.
Humans tend to conserve energy, often opting for the path of least resistance. While this can lead to poor choices, such as unhealthy eating or procrastinating, it can also be harnessed to your advantage. By increasing the challenges associated with stopping a habit or reducing the hurdles to starting one, you can facilitate the formation of desired habits.
Section 1.2: Making Resistance Work for You
For instance, I managed to start waking up earlier by establishing a fulfilling morning routine. I invested in a good coffee maker, sourced fresh bread, and began reading novels. Setting my alarm became easier with the anticipation of enjoying a delightful breakfast and a good book.
Additionally, I implemented a strict no-blue-light rule before bed, which became more manageable as I looked forward to reading rather than watching TV or scrolling through social media. By keeping my book in sight, I was motivated to rise early, and my evening routine naturally adjusted to this new habit.
In less than a week, I fully adapted to this schedule. By making the process of waking up earlier smoother and more appealing, I successfully integrated this new habit into my life.
Chapter 2: Embracing Setbacks as Learning Opportunities
It's vital to recognize that you may encounter setbacks along the way—this does not equate to failure. Instead of viewing a missed day as a defeat, consider it valuable feedback.
Research indicates that “missing one opportunity to perform the behavior did not materially affect the habit formation process.” For example, I aimed to eat healthier dinners but often resorted to quick, unhealthy meals when pressed for time.
To counter this, I devised a meal plan and completed my grocery shopping in advance. However, I sometimes struggled with the effort involved. Instead of giving up, I interpreted this as an indication that I needed a different approach. Ultimately, having groceries delivered weekly made healthy eating the easiest option for me.
By framing setbacks as stepping stones rather than failures, you can continue to move forward.
The Takeaway: Redefining Habit Formation
In summary, building habits is not a mystical process dictated by arbitrary timelines. It requires self-awareness and an understanding of your motivations. If a habit is truly important to you, focus on making it easier to engage in than to avoid.
Different strategies work for different individuals—some may thrive on public accountability, while others may benefit from physical barriers. Ultimately, the key is to recognize that setbacks are simply your brain guiding you toward a better approach.
It doesn’t take 21 days, divine intervention, or the approval of a productivity expert to cultivate meaningful habits. Instead, the goal is to simplify the process, making the desired behaviors the most accessible choice in your life.
Sign up here to get my Medium starter kit — everything you need to get started earning money by writing on Medium, including a printable day-by-day guide to your first week.