Chapter 1: The Routine of Health Advice

Reading health and wellness articles often feels repetitive, akin to the movie "Groundhog Day," prompting me to consider how authors arrive at their conclusions.

In "Groundhog Day," Bill Murray portrays a disheartened news reporter who must cover the same story each day. Similarly, I feel when I encounter articles offering tips on enhancing longevity. Whether it’s a list of five strategies to reduce cancer risk or ten ways to live longer, the recommendations are strikingly similar:

1. Avoid smoking. This is a straightforward recommendation. Despite decades of evidence linking smoking to cancer, heart disease, and COPD, some still overlook its dangers.
2. Prioritize sufficient sleep. This suggestion is overused and often oversimplified. Recent research highlights that both the quality and quantity of sleep matter, and excessive sleep can even be detrimental.
3. Limit alcohol consumption. My previous Medium article discussed this topic. While moderate drinking might have some benefits, heavy consumption is known to negatively impact health and longevity.
4. Minimize junk food intake. Junk food, now categorized as ultra-processed foods (UPF), is a significant contributor to obesity and disease. Foods like Twinkies and sugary cereals fall into this category. While causation between UPF and health issues is still being studied, evidence suggests reducing these foods is beneficial.
5. Consume more fruits and vegetables. Research strongly indicates that higher intake of these foods correlates with fewer chronic diseases. Among various diets, the Mediterranean Diet is particularly effective.
6. Steer clear of recreational drugs. It’s widely acknowledged that substances like heroin and cocaine are detrimental to health, and drugs like fentanyl pose serious risks.
7. Be aware of air pollution. A study in Asia indicated that air pollution negatively impacts health, but it’s unclear if tobacco use was adequately considered, which might skew the results.
8. Engage in regular exercise. The benefits of physical activity have long been debated, but most agree that some exercise is better than none. A routine of walking for 20-30 minutes several times a week can offer significant benefits.

These recommendations may seem like common sense, but their implications have often been overstated. For instance, the CDC's article "Six Tips to Enhance Immunity" reiterates many of these suggestions without presenting concrete data on how they specifically boost the immune system.

While I support these suggestions as generally beneficial, I notice a troubling trend of scientific complacency in the ongoing repetition of these guidelines without clear evidence of causation. It’s challenging to isolate a single habit to prove its direct impact, yet the persistence of these recommendations suggests there may be merit to them. However, conventional wisdom isn't always accurate; for instance, the notion that turkey induces sleepiness has been debunked.

Moreover, individuals who adopt healthy eating habits are typically less likely to smoke, misuse alcohol, or neglect exercise, making it challenging to isolate one factor's effects. Ultimately, there is no downside to maintaining a healthy lifestyle, but the medical community should strive for transparency and avoid rehashing the same generic list as a one-size-fits-all solution for every health concern.

David Mokotoff, MD

3.7K Followers

Book Author

Friend of Medium

I am a retired MD passionate about culture, health, sports, and food.