The Impact of Netflix on Global Culture and Media Dynamics
Written on
Chapter 1: The Global Reach of Netflix
As advancements in technology continue to reshape the media landscape, U.S. media companies are extending their influence internationally through internet-based television. This shift raises important questions about the political and social consequences of creating global entities. A significant concern is the potential for media and cultural imperialism.
The focus of this examination is on the insights provided by media scholars Stuart Davis and Ramon Lobato. While their research centers on Netflix, it highlights the broader trend of American companies seeking to enhance their global market presence. While Lobato maintains a more neutral stance regarding cultural and media imperialism, Davis argues that Netflix and similar companies exhibit tendencies of imperialism as they pursue monopolistic control in overseas markets (Davis, 2021).
In 2014, Catherine Tate, the president of CBC Canada, accused Netflix of media imperialism, likening its dominance to the colonization of smaller national media firms (Davis, 2021). Davis contends that Netflix's ambitions pose a threat to local media markets by striving for economic monopolization.
Despite the intent of streaming platforms like Netflix to offer diverse content, they inadvertently highlight the issue of media and cultural imperialism as they seek to dominate the industry. According to Davis, American media corporations engage in a hybrid form of media imperialism characterized by vertical integration that often overlooks local customs, accountability, and regulations.
Section 1.1: Divergent Perspectives on Cultural Threats
Conversely, Lobato argues that fears surrounding media and cultural imperialism may be exaggerated, particularly in countries with strong traditions and established local media. For instance, nations like China, India, and South Korea have their own successful streaming services that provide culturally relevant content. This illustrates the challenges faced by U.S. media companies in penetrating foreign markets.
Despite the existence of local content, audiences still gravitate towards American programming. Lobato posits that the discourse should not be framed as a binary opposition between globalization and culture but rather as an exploration of distribution, reception, economic structures, and consumer agency (Lobato, 2019). Instead of fixating on potential conflicts between content and culture, the focus should shift to accessibility, which does not inevitably lead to the Americanization of global markets.
Section 1.2: Evolving Streaming Regulations
Lobato also suggests that the evolution of the streaming industry has diminished the significance of cultural imperialism. Global markets have already implemented guidelines to protect local customs and media sectors. A notable example is the European Union's 2018 directive, which mandates that international streaming services meet a 20–30% quota for local content. This regulation compels streaming platforms to invest in European markets and contribute to national media industries.
Chapter 2: The Future of Local Cultures in a Globalized World
In contrast, Stuart warns that multinational corporations continue to pose risks to the preservation of local traditions, especially in developing countries with weaker infrastructures. These nations, with lower barriers to entry, might depend heavily on U.S.-based technological frameworks, putting them in vulnerable positions concerning their national interests.
Both Lobato and Stuart present compelling arguments about the potential dangers posed by Western corporations, emphasizing that the primary concern lies in media imperialism and the dominance of American media conglomerates in other nations. For its part, Netflix, as an American media corporation, does not inherently threaten local cultures; rather, it usually provides a diverse array of multicultural programming options. Instead of seeking to impose imperialistic cultural norms, American media companies often aim to monopolize the market and consolidate their influence.
The first video, "The Netflix Culture Memo and Diversity in the Digital Age," discusses how Netflix's corporate culture affects diversity and representation in its content.
The second video, "Netflix Culture Change," explores the evolution of Netflix’s corporate strategies and how they influence global media landscapes.