Chapter 1: Current Events in Social Media

Social media platforms frequently find themselves embroiled in turmoil, and Reddit is currently at the center of this chaos.

As we look at the unfolding situation, it’s important to understand the background. In April, Reddit’s CEO, Steve Huffman, made the announcement that the platform would start charging for API access. Essentially, Reddit sought to impose fees on third-party applications that had previously enjoyed free access to the platform’s data and functionality. Apollo, the largest alternative interface to Reddit, reported that they were asked to pay $12,000 for every 50 million requests. This drastic increase led developers to estimate their operational costs would soar to around $20 million annually. Consequently, Apollo declared it would shut down on June 30, just one day before the new fees were set to take effect.

“Like all blowups on Reddit, this one will pass.”

This remark opened the floodgates for reactions. Moderators expressed solidarity with the developers, fearing the potential disappearance of other essential third-party tools. As a result, thousands of subreddits went private, limiting access to their communities. These moderators relied on third-party tools to manage spam, flag inappropriate content, and maintain effective communication with their users. The absence of these tools significantly complicates their operations.

Shortly after, Huffman was interviewed by The Verge, providing him an opportunity to smooth tensions and possibly reverse some of the proposed changes. Instead, he reinforced his stance, stating, “Like all blowups on Reddit, this one will pass.” He emphasized that Reddit, being an 18-year-old company, needed to adapt and become profitable. This perspective is hard to contest, especially given the speculation about a potential IPO since 2021. For any IPO to succeed, it’s essential that the company demonstrates profitability, particularly in today's challenging venture capital landscape.

Adding to the complexity is the rise of A.I. and chatbots, such as ChatGPT. Huffman expressed frustration that these companies have leveraged Reddit's valuable data to train their bots without compensation, subsequently generating significant profits. By implementing fees for API access, Reddit aims to require these companies to pay for future data usage.

The situation continues to evolve. While around 80% of the top 5,000 subreddits have resumed normal operations, some still remain private. The CEO remains steadfast in his approach. A group of hackers has even threatened Reddit, demanding $4.5 million along with changes to the controversial API fees. They claim to have breached the platform's systems earlier this year, stealing 80GB of data, and have threatened to release this information if their demands aren’t met. Nonetheless, it appears that these changes will be enforced, compelling third-party applications to either adapt by monetizing their services or face closure.

This saga raises intriguing questions about the future landscape of the internet. If the only solution to combat A.I. bots scraping our data or ensuring that content is created by humans is to place everything behind paywalls, we may need to prepare ourselves to pay for the applications and services we currently use for free. What alternative do we have? Should we allow A.I. language models to exploit our data without any compensation while profiting immensely? It falls upon us, the users, to champion this cause and support the services we value.

Pay for it, or lose it.

Consider Apollo. They quickly recognized that a $20 million annual cost was unsustainable. However, with approximately 900,000 daily users and over 5 million downloads, it’s likely that some users pay for the app's two subscription tiers, priced at $4.99 and $12.99. Yet, when the app's survival was at stake, why couldn't they introduce another tier, such as $20 annually, to inform their loyal users that this was essential for the app’s continuation? Most would probably hesitate, which ultimately leads to its impending shutdown. The issue lies not just with the API fees—an understandable business move by Reddit—but with users’ unwillingness to pay.

Similar patterns can be observed with Twitter. Musk anticipated that implementing paywalls for features would encourage users to subscribe, as they would want access and support the platform by reducing advertisements. However, this hasn’t materialized; the current number of new signups is around 640,000, while the site boasts over 350 million users. Although animosity toward Musk may distort this situation, the reality remains that many users resist opening their wallets for services they’ve grown accustomed to using for free.

The ongoing drama at Reddit could signify the onset of a necessary shift in our online interactions. This might mark the beginning of an evolution in the internet where we will have to pay for each app and service we wish to access. While Reddit and Twitter's approaches may not be perfect, it’s challenging to introduce charges without provoking backlash. However, as we advance into an A.I.-dominated future, paying for the services we utilize might be the only means to ensure the survival of these platforms.

It would be overly dramatic to declare the end of the "open internet," yet we are witnessing the gradual decline of the social media era. With that decline, the advertising model that sustained these platforms is also faltering. Might the very essence of the internet—its openness—be the next aspect that requires transformation?

If you found this analysis insightful, consider subscribing for bi-weekly perspectives on Big Tech, the Metaverse, and more.

Chapter 2: The Implications of Paywalls

In the video titled "Discussing the Hearthstone Subreddit Drama," we explore the reactions and implications of the recent Reddit controversies.

The second video, "BREAKS GONE WRONG GONE SEXUAL - Reddit r/Subredditdrama," delves into the broader themes of user engagement and platform policies.