Avoiding Bankruptcy: The Critical Role of Inventory Management
Written on
Understanding the Dangers of Excess Inventory
A staggering statistic from the Small Business Administration reveals that around 90% of new enterprises fail within a decade. The question arises: why do so many businesses collapse? In my observations, particularly among small enterprises, excessive capital tied up in unsold inventory often leads to financial ruin, primarily due to inadequate inventory management. Indeed, having an abundance of dead inventory can spell disaster for entrepreneurs, irrespective of their industry.
This narrative revolves around three small businesses I am familiar with that succumbed to bankruptcy due to overwhelming dead inventory.
The Computer Repair Shop
Prior to my college years, I worked as a technician in a small computer repair shop, earning a mere $6.50 per hour—just above the minimum wage in 2005. This job was seen as an opportunity for valuable experience.
The shop's owner, while saving on labor costs, compensated by overstocking the store with an excessive amount of inventory that remained largely unsold. Competing against larger retailers like Staples, Best Buy, Office Depot, and even online giants like Amazon was a losing battle for this small business.
A notable feature was a long display case filled with hard drives and USB drives, priced two to three times higher than similar products at competing stores. The aisles were cluttered with cables, printer supplies, network adapters, and various computer accessories, most of which were only touched for dusting.
Ultimately, the computer repair shop failed. The owner found himself with too much capital tied in unsold products, which he either couldn't or wouldn't liquidate at reasonable prices. Despite being a skilled technician and a genuinely nice individual, he allowed an ineffective office manager to persuade him into opening a retail space alongside his repair services. The financial losses in inventory must have amounted to tens of thousands of dollars.
The Farm Supply and Feed Store
During my junior year in college, I joined a SIFE (Students in Free Enterprise) team tasked with assisting a small business on the verge of bankruptcy. We worked with a farm supply and feed store in a rural area that had been operational for decades. The elderly owners clung to outdated business practices from a time when online shopping and discount retailers were nonexistent.
Initially, the couple thrived by stocking their store with surplus inventory, including clothing and household goods. However, the arrival of discount retailers like Walmart and Dollar General, along with the rise of eCommerce platforms like Amazon, diminished the need for their diverse inventory.
As part of our initiative, we were allowed to review their financial records, which was my first encounter with a balance sheet reflecting owner equity—something that had not been covered in my accounting classes! Our findings revealed that the store was still profitable in selling feed to local farmers, as demand remained strong in the region.
We suggested that the owners liquidate their unsold inventory and reinvest in their feed business. Unfortunately, they dismissed our advice, and the store ultimately shut down the following year.
The Carpet Store
My college investments professor shared stories from his past, including the time he opened a carpet store in Kansas City in the early 1980s. To attract more customers, he invested heavily in a wide selection of carpets, aiming to cater to a broad audience.
However, the economic landscape of the early '80s was challenging, marked by high interest rates and inflation that severely impacted consumer spending. My professor's business eventually fell victim to these economic conditions.
In class, he asked if anyone had ever seen a balance sheet with negative owner equity. Reflecting on the feed store's financial struggles, I raised my hand, prompting him to offer to show us his old financial statements, albeit with some reluctance.
His experience highlights the pitfalls of overextending a business. Instead of trying to cater to everyone, he might have succeeded by focusing on a specific niche market.
The first video, "Top 5 Reasons Small Businesses Fail - and what to do about it!" provides insights into the common pitfalls that lead to small business failures and offers strategies to overcome these challenges.
The second video, "Mark Cuban - The #1 Reason Why Most People Fail In Business," features Mark Cuban discussing the primary reasons behind business failures and how to avoid them.
If you found this narrative insightful and would like to support me and countless other writers, consider subscribing to Medium for just $5 a month or $50 a year.