Section 1.1: The Created Perspective

Some theorists assert that mathematics is a human-made construct, a sophisticated tool designed to help us navigate and make sense of the world around us. In this view, mathematical concepts are mental frameworks crafted to organize and explain natural patterns. Here, mathematicians resemble architects, systematically designing structures that align with the reality we observe.

A prominent example of this viewpoint is found in geometry, particularly with the evolution of non-Euclidean geometries. During the 19th century, mathematicians such as Carl Friedrich Gauss, János Bolyai, and Nikolai Lobachevsky began to question the long-standing dominance of Euclidean geometry, which had been accepted as the only valid form for centuries.

Euclidean geometry, established by the ancient Greek mathematician Euclid, is founded on five postulates that outline the properties of points, lines, and planes. However, these mathematicians ventured into alternative geometrical realms by challenging the parallel postulate, which asserts that through any point not on a given line, only one parallel line can be drawn.

Gauss and his contemporaries posited that the parallel postulate might not be an absolute truth but rather an assumption. They developed non-Euclidean geometries where this postulate did not apply, illustrating that different, internally consistent geometrical systems could exist, thereby challenging the idea that geometry is an undisputed truth discovered in the external world.

Section 1.2: The Discovered Perspective

On the other hand, advocates of the discovered perspective argue that mathematical truths exist apart from human thought. In this view, mathematicians are explorers unearthing pre-existing mathematical realities. The elegance and universality of mathematical concepts—such as the Fibonacci sequence or the Pythagorean theorem—hint at a realm of eternal truths awaiting revelation.

A commonly referenced example in this perspective is prime numbers. These are natural numbers greater than one that possess no positive divisors other than one and themselves. Proponents of the discovered perspective maintain that prime numbers are not mere products of human thought but rather inherent mathematical truths that exist independently.

The division between creation and discovery may be a false dilemma. Mathematics embodies a unique duality; it is both a product of human ingenuity and a discovery within the universe's structure. Humans create mathematical language and symbols to express abstract ideas, yet these ideas often unveil profound truths about the universe's inherent order.

Mathematics occupies a space that intertwines art and science. It serves as a canvas where human creativity paints intricate patterns that resonate with the hidden structures of reality. The interplay between creation and discovery in mathematics highlights the complex and mysterious relationship between human intellect and the underlying order of the cosmos.

The enduring question remains captivating. It is within the synthesis of these perspectives that we may uncover the true essence of mathematics—an artful creation that reflects the awe-inspiring discoveries embedded within the very fabric of our reality.

The first video titled "Roger Penrose - Is Mathematics Invented or Discovered?" explores the philosophical implications of these two contrasting views on mathematics.

The second video, "Is math discovered or invented? - Jeff Dekofsky," further delves into this intriguing debate, offering insights into the nature of mathematical truths.

Thank you for your attention, and if you found this discussion valuable, please consider subscribing to my page for more insights.

Until next time, au revoir!!!