A Practical Guide to Disproving the Flat Earth Hypothesis
Written on
Understanding the Flat Earth Debate
Recently, we’ve been inundated with inquiries regarding the increasingly popular “Flat Earth hypothesis.” Just a few days ago, we received a particular question:
"Hello. Is there a straightforward method to determine at home whether the Earth is flat or spherical, without needing costly equipment or space travel?"
Refuting the notion of a flat Earth can be complex. Technically, it doesn't even qualify as a theory in scientific terms, since a theory is a comprehensive framework that aligns with established scientific facts. The “theory” of a flat Earth is riddled with inconsistencies. While we have previously discussed simple methods to confirm the Earth’s spherical nature, we will explore another approach given the ongoing inquiries.
The celestial pole is a point on the celestial sphere around which the apparent daily motion of stars occurs, attributable to Earth's rotation. In the Northern Hemisphere, this is represented by the Pole Star (Polaris), while in the Southern Hemisphere, it is Sigma Octans.
Imagining a line through Earth’s rotational axis, it will direct toward the Pole Star in the northern region and Sigma Octantis in the southern region.
For this experiment, you won't need anything sophisticated. All you require is a protractor, a thread with a weight (a standard nut will suffice), and a clear night to observe the Pole Star well.
Creating a Simple Inclinometer
Let’s construct a device to measure the angular height of the Pole Star. Take a protractor and attach a weighted thread at its midpoint, as illustrated in the accompanying diagram.
Now that you have your basic inclinometer, align it with the Pole Star so that the base of the protractor connects your eye to the Pole Star. Subtract 90 degrees from the angle indicated by the weighted thread on the protractor. The resulting value represents the angular height of the Pole Star.
This measurement also reveals your geographic latitude. Regardless of where you conduct this experiment—whether at the North Pole or the equator—the angular height of the Pole Star will correspond to your geographic latitude. Isn’t that convenient? This principle has been known for centuries and is utilized by navigators for celestial navigation.
Why This Works
The effectiveness of this method is attributed to the vast distance to the Pole Star, approximately 447 light-years from Earth. Consequently, the rays of light from the Pole Star are effectively parallel, regardless of where on Earth the measurements are taken. This principle holds true on a spherical Earth, as demonstrated below:
On the other hand, this approach would fail on a flat Earth. If the Earth were flat, the angular height of the Pole Star would remain constant across all measurement points, rendering it ineffective for determining geographical coordinates.
Even if we were to entertain the idea that the Pole Star isn’t as distant as scientific evidence suggests, it still contradicts the flat Earth concept. First, this viewpoint conflicts with basic geometry. It’s straightforward to confirm that the angular height of the Pole Star corresponds to geographic latitude.
Each degree of latitude is approximately 111 kilometers apart. Assuming the Pole Star is directly above the North Pole of a hypothetical “flat Earth” (as viewed from the North Pole), its height should measure 5767 kilometers when viewed from 60 degrees north latitude, 4994 kilometers from 45 degrees north latitude, and 3845 kilometers from 30 degrees north latitude. At the equator, the Pole Star should be directly overhead.
Thus, basic geometry and fundamental observations once again disprove the notion that the Earth is flat.
Engagement and Support
If you would like to see more content about space in your feed, please give us a clap! Subscribe to our channel and feel free to ask any questions, which I will address in future articles. If you appreciate my work, consider supporting me by becoming a Medium member for just $5 a month, helping us create even better content.
Chapter 2: Video Insights on Flat Earth
This video, "The Flat Earth Theory Explained | Dom Joly," provides a clear breakdown of the flat Earth argument and counterpoints, making it an essential watch.
In "Neil Tyson Demonstrates Absurdity of 'Flat Earth'," Neil deGrasse Tyson highlights the irrationality of the flat Earth claims, providing scientific clarity.